Discussion about this post

User's avatar
...'s avatar

as a young person myself who is learning from textbooks just like these, this is no surprise to me. i'm pretty politically involved so i know what stuff's biased, but there are tons of people who enter HS apolitical and leave thinking that american history is uniquely evil, the american dream is dead, and climate change is the #1 thread to existence. conservatives need to wake up to what's happening in our classrooms if we want to avoid having a misanthropic generation that hates our country.

Expand full comment
Adrian Gaty's avatar

Great reporting! But as you know, every page of those textbooks is like that. There is no neutrality possible in education and they know it…

“ when Harvard adopted its motto, Veritas, in 1643, its Puritan founders were referring not to CDC fact checks, but to God’s Truth. Apparently that wasn’t clear enough for some, so by 1650 they changed the motto to In Christi Gloriam (“For the Glory of Christ”).

Did settlers in faraway Ohio a century and a revolution later share Harvard’s, er, “emphasis”? Per McCullough, the driving force behind the Northwest Ordinance’s stance on education – as well as its abolition of slavery – was Manasseh Cutler. To be precise, the Reverend Manasseh Cutler. Here is a typical thought of his, from a sermon he gave in the new territory he had so much to do with establishing:

Such is the present state of things in this country, that we have just ground to hope that religion and learning, the useful and ornamental branches of science, will meet with encouragement, and that they will be extended to the remotest parts of the American empire … Here may the Gospel be preached to the latest period of time; the arts and sciences be planted; the seeds of virtue, happiness, and glory be firmly rooted and grow up to full maturity.

If that passage were ever to be assigned in an Ohio public school today, it would come with a trigger warning. ”

More here:

https://gaty.substack.com/p/mcculloughs-mistake-and-ours

Expand full comment
22 more comments...

No posts